| 2023 | Sarah Eberspaicher | University of Nebraska - Lincoln
|
| 2022 | Nigel Lancaster
| Ohio State University
|
| 2019 | Julia Roshelli
| University of Findlay
|
| 2018 | Connor Smith | St. Andrew's University |
| 2017 | Brittany Abernathy | North Eastern Oklahoma A&M College |
| 2016 | Michelle McDowel | Grand Valley State University |
| 2015 | Selena Finn | University of Nebraska-Lincoln |
| 2014 | Julia Roberts | West Texas A & M University |
| 2013 | Austin Griffith | Ohio State University |
| 2012 | Austin Griffith | Ohio State University |
| 2011 | Rebekah Irish | Black Hawk College |
| 2010 | Jason Romney | Utah State University |
| 2009 | Jennifer Nagel | State University of New York at Oswego |
| 2008 | Katelyn Moorehead | University of Findlay |
| 2007 | Trevor Dare | University of Findlay |
| 2006 | Travis Womer | Unoversity of Findlay |
| 2005 | Jacob Bowman | University of Findlay |
| 2004 | Kristin Dickerson | Oklahoma State University |
| 2003 | Sarah Elder | Middle Tennessee State University |
| 2002 | Quincy Cahill | Texas A & M University |
| 2001 | Quincy Cahill | Texas A & M University |
| 2000 | Quincy Cahill | Texas A & M University |
| 1999 | Laura Phillips | Ohio State University |
| 1998 | Elissa Lane | California State University-Fresno |
| 1997 | Stephanie Harrison | California Polytech at Pomona |
| 1996 | Jill Nicole Soronen | Ohio State University |
| 1995 | Tammy Jo Greeman | New Mexico State University |
| 1994 | Molly Rinedollar | Colorado State University |
| 1993 | Rich Beidelscheis | Ohio State University |
| 1992 | Patty SImon | Texas A & M |
| 1991 | Valerie Fites | Kent State University |
| 1990 | Susan Pfessteil | Western Kentucky University |
| 1989 | Christine Cognetti | Saint Lawrence University |
| 1988 | Meg Rothermich | Miami University of Ohio |
| 1987 | Cathy Woosley | Midway College |
| 1986 | Ellen Nagel | Pennsylvania State University |
| 1985 | Duvid Davis | Morehead State University |
| 1984 | Tom Walmsley | University of Illinois |
| 1983 | Janet Ross | Tennessee State University |
| 1982 | Katrina Jerger | Murray State University |